Straight answers

The New New Jersey Paint Laws: What They Mean for Rusty Metal

By Brian Egert, owner of Egert Painting. November 2026.

Rust coming through the paint on a steel generator fuel tank

If you manage a school, an office building or any commercial property in New Jersey, you’ve probably heard oil-based paint is being banned. That’s not exactly true. It’s not being banned, but it’s being limited drastically.

What actually changed

New Jersey has rules on how much VOC can be in a can of paint. In 2025 the state made those rules stricter. They didn’t ban oil-based paint by name, they just put a limit on what’s in the can, and a lot of the old oil-based paints can’t meet it. So the manufacturers stop making them and they slowly disappear off the shelves.

Some solvents and thinners got stricter too. It depends on the product, so if you hear someone saying everything is banned, that’s not necessarily true.

Why this matters to me

I’ve painted thousands of commercial doors with Sherwin-Williams Industrial Enamel, which is oil-based. I kept using it for a few reasons. It dries hard. It holds up to the oils on people’s hands, which matters on a door that gets pushed hundreds of times a day. On steel doors that already have some rust, oil-based paint is a natural rust inhibitor. And it was ready for abuse fairly quickly, almost the next day, even before it had fully cured.

You can still buy it and use it while the old stock is still around, but it’s not being made the old way anymore. Once it’s gone, it’s gone. So I’ve been forced to make a switch.

What I’m using now

The biggest question I had was simple. Is there a water-based paint that can take the abuse a commercial door takes?

Here’s what I’ve been using:

Sherwin-Williams Pro Industrial Waterbased Alkyd Urethane. I like this product. It levels out well, it feels a little like painting with oil, and it seems to dry very hard. Sherwin-Williams says it’s dry to the touch in 1 to 2 hours and ready to recoat in 12, and their lab rates its resistance to lanolin, basically hand oil, as excellent. That sounds good on paper, but I need real-world testing. I haven’t seen the long-term results yet, and the longer cure time could be an issue.

Benjamin Moore Command. A water-based urethane for doors, handrails and high-traffic surfaces. It dries a little faster than the Sherwin-Williams product, and it also seems to dry fairly hard. Benjamin Moore claims it can go back into service fast: dry to the touch in 15 minutes, recoat in an hour, foot traffic in 4 hours and full return to service in 24 hours. That’s a big claim, and I need real-world testing to see if a door that’s opened and closed 500 times a day actually holds up that soon. Same thing, I don’t know the long-term results yet.

Sherwin-Williams Pro-Cryl Universal Primer. A water-based primer made to resist rust. I haven’t used this one yet. More on this below.

What about rust?

This was my other big worry. The oil-based paint itself is a natural rust inhibitor. Water-based topcoats don’t work the same way, so now more of the rust protection has to come from the primer underneath.

I’m still working this out, so I won’t pretend I have a proven system yet. Here’s one option I plan to test on rusty doors, frames and railings. It’s also the system Sherwin-Williams recommends for steel, one coat of Pro-Cryl and two coats of the alkyd urethane:

  1. Clean off the grease, dirt and hand oils.

  2. Scrape, wire-brush and sand off the loose rust and failing paint.

  3. Prime with a rust-inhibitive primer like Pro-Cryl.

  4. Two topcoats of one of the water-based enamels above.

I’ll know a lot more once I’ve seen how it holds up over time, and I’ll post my results in a later article.

Long side of a rusted generator fuel tank before painting, Ewing Township, NJ

Before

The same fuel tank primed and coated in gloss black urethane, Ewing Township, NJ

After

Our work: a rusted fuel tank under a bank’s standby generator in Ewing Township, primed over the rust and coated in gloss black urethane.

Can you paint over the old oil-based paint?

Usually, yes. If the old paint is in good shape, I don’t need to strip every door back to bare metal. I clean it, take off anything loose, and scuff the glossy surface so the new coat has something to grip. If a door is in bad shape or rust is coming through underneath, it’s going to need more prep, and maybe a grinder.

A couple of things worth knowing

This is a big one. Water-based enamels feel dry pretty quickly, but in the past they’ve taken a lot longer to get fully cured. For the first couple of weeks, the customer would have to go easy on scrubbing them with strong cleaners and be a little careful with the doors. After that they’re good for normal use.

The upside is less smell and less disruption. That’s a real plus in a school or an office where people can’t just clear out for a few days.

The downside is this. When I painted doors with oil, they were back in use the next day, despite not being cured yet. With water-based paint, they’re dry but still soft for a while, and a busy door gets beat up fast. That’s the problem I’m trying to solve, and I should have an answer shortly after my testing.

The bottom line

The rules changed, so the products changed. What a door has to stand up to hasn’t. It still has to handle people’s oily hands, cleaning and weather, and the steel still has to be protected from rust. I’ve spent a lot of years learning what makes a commercial door finish last, and I’m taking that into these new products instead of starting from scratch.

Got rusty metal that needs paint?

Doors, frames, railings, stairways, or any rusty metal around your building. If it’s peeling, rusting, or just looks like it needs another coat of paint, give us a call. I’ll come out, look at what you’ve got, and tell you honestly what it needs.

Egert Painting, commercial painting for property managers, schools and building owners across New Jersey.

Still weighing it up?

See how rusty steel and metal are usually handled.

Doors, frames, railings, siding and tanks: what the prep and coatings usually involve.

Get a quote

Tell us about the metal.

Tell us what you’re looking at and where the building is. If you’d rather talk it through, call.

What happens next

01

You call or send the form

02

We look and estimate

03

We plan around you

04

Work, clean up, hand back

Request a quote

Tell us about the job. Prefer to talk? Call (732) 814-4888.

We use your details only to reply to you. Privacy notice

Get a quote

Tell us about the metal.

Tell us what you’re looking at and where the building is. If you’d rather talk it through, call.

Request a quote

Tell us about the job. Prefer to talk? Call (732) 814-4888.

We use your details only to reply to you. Privacy notice

Get a quote

Tell us about the metal.

Tell us what you’re looking at and where the building is. If you’d rather talk it through, call.

Request a quote

Tell us about the job. Prefer to talk? Call (732) 814-4888.

We use your details only to reply to you. Privacy notice